GLITCHMAN
SIGHTING THE DUST
Rg L c c
R fgs f sg C s ?ss c f s sg L sg fg s P c
Wh d i igh h d d thi k h h gh i id A d id ily h (Q ti f p i l y l k l t id
lly i ) I hi i l I id h i pli i f t h d p i lly b ly f Wh d h
di g t id
ti b i g t
light H ight it p p i g th diff tly th i
My h i ith h igh tit t id i d f th
b t ti ly d t ph i lly (t t g i th t l ly ly th th ) My i t t i i i th l ki g t i f h p
t lik id th l y b th lyti l t ti f id l ibly g i y d d y dg d
by p d h ight ll ill Wh t th ff d i pli ti
gh i
- k B
- d l g H I h ld h i p y h l gy hc k h hi g diff t f th i bj t f f it i th b kg d i th t p d p b bly ith t b i g f it S g d id l tt ti di t ti g p i g f b i g bl
l gi l
f t t
p ti l tt p y h l gi t
h l gy l gy
f bj ti g th t
t t t th t k t h d My f th t h i i t d d t ig l f h t i t lly ti d i d i d di g i thi
f B t h h t d t hi i ly p i l I i b i g
hi h f
B l I fl
id lity
gi f ll ti t h id l d h di i f th ti f id i g t i i b l
diff
f l t d t h t d t Thi fl ti l d t ph l gy
f id t g th ith id ti f th i t l gi l i pli ti p i lly f th t k y ti y th bj t Th ti l th pl t t f pl i hi h id d th id l i ly b ght t i Th
fi t p pl d p i ily f h g phi h l i g
i R p di g t i i id p i lly d h i ly l p i l t l gi f t i l d bj t d l h h
Thi k i d t p t f th Cl t f E ll M t f A ti ity (DFG EXC 2025)
ithi it Obj t Sp Ag y th I th k Ni S l d F li S t l f th i it ti t t ib t thi
l d f th i g t d y h lpf l gg ti I l g t f l
t th Ahkc k c Vh dit i l t p ti l ly M tthi B h f i ightf l dit i l i p t
Ly St i p d th t t ith ll t py diti g G d Fyf g id d t h P th bl d g t f ; J i M g d M g t O ld ll d t f
th i y p bli h d k Cl Wi kl t ly g t f hi hibit b t l h d d ft f hi p bli h d k d y id d th i Mik B y t f p
p ith h i titl
G g B t ill D fi iti f H t l gy I Th y C lt d S i y l 35 20 8 4 5 pp
29 40
No @ © 1/11 Rg L c c o a s C F xs
C V j s s s c B s B @ss a s 3 / s s K gss ..c f. / 4 4.8 72 / 222 //
id gl d i d ff d p i l f l b d p i f i d liti
p p ti p ifi hi hi
i l di g th f p i Th d p f i ll i k tly lf g i d i i th
h b h i I th i b i gi g f h id l t t i h y t p b p ti l d t di g f t i lity d bj t ll th t
d p t ti l f th it lf
? og fx e c
R id by p d f h t i g d d h i ph b t Th y id h h d ty l gy i pli th id di t
h b th t p ti g f li gi g dg A id i h hi h i l f b hi d f ll i g p Al h gh id y b d
pl t th y t l ly d ig t d g ti bbi h d t N ith d th y g t h tt ti Th ly p i l bi i
t d l ith h Whil id gligibl th bbi h d t th y lly l d li t th t d t ll f d t k U lik
d k id d i k h gl l f l di g t hidd
h gh id h h lip i k i i g th dg f p p t b t d l i d t i t y A hi i l d i d d hi
igh
l
h l gg h i h p f id t b i ly bili d l f d i d t ti k
I th i l f b hi d id diff f hi h pill t
f it f th b t 2 E f l j y ly ff i tt i ly i ky
id t ll E d big hi i C ly S
t By t t id t f d t i i l y b h h t b hi h k bl
t ti ly p
d p i
i t i t p h p b i f id p h l p i lly if b i i d h h d
d t h ; h i l f d h t i g 3 D
l h b
i i i i 4 N
i lly h bj t
i lik ly t b i p t p d f p ti l f th t bj t it ly b k
h i d d d t i i it lf i ig i g t thi k ith d th gh l t f i
2 S Sh M d ld J i M g H ld F dh i T M y Thi g t K p f th F t
I R d y H i C itli D Sil y C li H lt f Sh M d ld N di B t li i E th B ith ff H ld F dh i A y Ly S h M y J i M g S f y P ( d ) H i g F t C p ti App h t N l d C lt l H it g P ti L d 2020 pp 55 68 f fl ti d f t i l di g
3 C ly St d D t Th A hi d C lt l Hi t y N B i k NJ 2002 p 63
4 S J ph A A t D t A Hi t y f th S ll d I i ibl B k l y 2000; Mi h l M d D t
N Y k 20 6; d St d ( t 3)
ph i i h d h p li ity f it d f i g t b h b t
d th t f g ti g id f th b t Pl yi g ith h b l q i k ld y h c i t k h c ah g c h gh S d
ph i d t d i f i h I i b i l ity th i p ibility f thi g di pp i g g i g y b i g g 5 Thi th t d t i e
ll bj t d h lik th id it i i h tly i b t t ly bl i g b t l ttli g h (id f) th bj t it lf
Q h d
h id
i i t f h
h th
l t d t b t
hc p h p th l t t hc f i l i h f t lly h y b f h id Th y b f R id by t typi l
ll h p d d l h th
ly thi g l
hi g Th di t th b t f i b l i t i j t th li l i id k ttl i t Th y d t bl th ll R id
thi g t hi g i h l Th i l ft f y b th i i f
p d d di t h q liti ith
f t) L fh d o hog h
d bi f (h i id t l t t ph i
lly B t id t p i ily
p g phi l M h t h y gi l p iph l h i
(b h) t i ily p t y M gi d p iph i li g h i k ly d d i gly R id l ti l b h y i by h y d (Thi h ld i d i id t lly h t fig i g diff t
d f l ti li y i i p t t lyti l t k d t hi h t ti t th di ff d d ph l gy f ki d f f b t h h t t ib t )
M th ti d pl y th t hc t d ib h t i l ft b hi d ft p
i l l l ti M id h i l Th y b h t
h th t igh dip fi g i h gh p h p ly ily i h y
p t b t i P h p g itty g y id y h f d i l ti liq id lid t i i g l y ki h t y it lf b f i d i
i d i y Th i i b t t i p d d by h f t h t th y ith th i b bj t th l th i th f th t
id t R id d bly ltiply li i l Y t ti i i h d t y h th thi g i id th thi g it lf I it p i di t A b th
id S h q i h p ti l l i Sh ld h id b id d p f bj hi g t b d A id h l hip h
5 S d ( 3) p 64
d l p ly by h h i q i h t l gi l t f bj
h di i d h gi g p i di g th 6 By j t li gi g bj b l b i g p d
id d f i t id
h l Wh d bj b gi d d
R id i thi q i i t p l f t A h y t ti p h p l g p i d th y f i g h bj t th y p t f i At th l
id ll p d ti p i g; th y b it t th b i g hi y t th p t t t Phil ph Ti thy M t gg t th t ll thi g t g t di ty i
ll h hi g t t i h i i d h y g l g i h i 7 R id
y b l i ly t bl d l d h d h d ty l gy i h hc
gg b t th y lik ly b ill i h ki g l i ly fi
- g l l hi i g l f t p h p f ti i g d p iti Al h gh id y i d ti ti f p th ti ti th y l
i d f h t h g d th i lt ly i d di pp fi it d
( d bl d t y p t i l f d t hi h C ly St d l p i t t) 8
Thi ki g f id ti i t lly th lt f p p f l h
i d i ti l f th l R h id ill h t bj ill ib i h t b i g p h d 9 Th y if th ti ity f t d
ip f t i f th Cl t f E ll f hi h hi l p i g N j p idi g id th t d thi g by i lf d th t bj
d t i l t i id i th q i f p i ly h ki d f ti ity i l d d ith h t ff t
t t pl f id i i d t ill i t bj t th t i t lly gi th y tt ti by l gy (th d i dy d i h th d p i i f ) R id h
h b h f p ti l t i p i lly i th fi ld f
| d g phy hi h d l ith p i l d i h f f id p d |
ti ( hi h i i b d
di i f th ) I i t
b y d h i ti g pp h d i t l gy d th fi ld b i gi g
p p ti i t d t th
6 F l t d b t f pl S h W ld Th R i h d I g H t R i M t pi
by R t ti L d 985; d Mi h l D l y S l t Ab I Si J K ll ( d ) C f C l
l ti L d 994 pp 30 34
7 Ti thy M t B i g E l gi l L d 20 8 p 69
8 St d ( 3) p 63
9 Ibid p 7
| B | e | f | |||||||||||
| O | f th | y i | hi h | id | if i | i | p bl | h | d | b | |||
| l | d | y Lit l | l gi | l | t i h | b gi | th l | i g | f | ||||
b l i g p ti h b ig ifi t i h g phi h
pp h ll t d t th id l A th p l gi t J i M g b i t t d i di d p ti f l i g h th b highly t d i h h d bb d l i g t h h it K l i g A t G ll y d
i Gl g S tl d 10 Th l i g b k t ft th
d d i it ki g i i i b f b i g j dg d i ffi i ly
| h ff f l b i i i di pl y Typi lly |
l Th ff di g id hi h h d l d l f t p i ily b f d
h y k h f f d t d fi g p i t h g y ki g h gl f
ithi th A M g pl i f th id
ti g f th p pl h t i h hibit Vi it pt li d by t ff h y h i li d t d p litt pi i i
th y h ld b i g di t i th i b di t d t by h ddi g h i d ki
d t h d bj ith h i i ky fi g l i g h d 1 A t di g h id b i g ligh d di g f i i phy i lly i d
D fyi g l l gi l d t di g f i it l h h y pp h b di d ly d lik h id th l g i
M g p i t t d i g Mi h l T ig id f d d di t t g i b 12
| ti g th i f th t t D i g ti g t th K l i g |
B t it i t ly h h t h t g d by d th t l d t th l
A G ll y d M p d t di pl y d th g p i d hi k l y f g y d th h d g th d i b t pi f f i d l P p
A ffi t d d yly Wh y d t i h d h
h l dy d [ ] f i j t y d y b ildi g 3
0 J i M g Ch g d E yd y P ti t th M A Eth g phi St dy U p bli h d
PhD h i i ity f M h 20 p 90
Ibid p 94
J i M g Th Cl i g C pb d A Eth g phi L k th P d ti f N i
K l i g A t G ll y d M I F i d i h B K ti P hl F k S h id A tt S h l ( d ) M X Z N g i h di i l R B li Blätt 57
B li 20 pp 49 56 h p 5 M g it Mi h l T ig My C i M Chi g 2004
p iii
3 M g Ch g d E yd y ( 0) p 94
Rg L c kc
Th b ildi g it lf i ti i ki g h d t M
M g h t i l f h di pl y p i lly h gl k id
h d d fi g p i t ll h i ibl I d d h h t i f
l d th k d d t i id h y b id 4 Th i t ti f b t i l d light g t t ti t id th t ight th i h i d ti d M t ff th k ith t l gi f tt
ti d t ly i l ti t bj t M tt (i thi d t) i t i ply ti h it b h d i t t i p ti l y hi h th
y b di g A M g d ib i f i i g di i f th k f l h i di p t b th h b li h l i g ( i g
l th d h i l ) i t ff i d h h y h t ly d y l i g ( i g d d l ) lt i p p ly id f E h id l i t ly th t th p ti f th th f il t ff ti ly id b t h t th y ly di t ib t d l d t f th S h di p t t h
ly b t th pp d f t d p ti liti th y l M g h b d p ith ti l d hi hi Th l tt i l d h d
g h l f h i l t ithi h h h y h l
i y y lik th d t d g i h t h y k d t l y d f igh Thi i p d i th i f h h i k i li it d by t
h d d bj 5
Diff ti ti f id d th i gl t i b y d th i di ly p ti l l d i M g t O ld th g phy f th Eth l gi l M i B li 16 I th t ff h i d b t d t
hi h h it ti d i pl y y 17 Th i h b ki d f d t th t t ff h ll d 8 Thi i d h
bj i ithi th S ff g d hi ki d f ff th bj t d by th h h i p f h bj t ll lif hi h i l d it i i h ll h t b f it H diff
id t j t b t h th id p t f bj t b t l b t th
l i bj p bi g phy F th t h d t ly i it t th k f th i t f th bj t t th t f
4 M g Cl i g C pb d ( 2) p 54
5 M g Ch g d E yd y ( 0) p 208
6 S M g t O ld W ki g Th gh C l i l C ll i A Eth g phy f th Eth l g
7 i l M i B li L id 2022 h pt 7Ibid
8 Ibid
i q i iti hi y i ly h t h pp d b f h d F h illi g t b th d bj t p i i h i p f it ti i g lif
| d lif t y Th gh h l f d th | j | diff | t | t l gi | |||||||
| f h t i l d b t l diff | p i | f | h | ightf | l g y | ||||||
| d f th y id f bj | |||||||||||
| Alth gh d t i ti | g | d d | l ti ly h | l | id | O ld | |||||
| p i t t th t it i t | ily | h by | ff | i | it | y h b | |||||
| d gi g b t lif f Oth ki d f id p i lly f p i | |||||||||||
| p p d bj h l i i h t bj p pl ( l C i l i hi l |
p d b d gi g
) I th f th l gi l h t i i y f li p i id i f ith h k
| bj t by th f bj t th i i i Th tit ti f bj t l d b k t hi ti l |
9
id l ith
q ti f p i M l i f h ldi g t bj t b d i p t th id th t th y t k h b f h bj t d p t t h f p bl ti
id Th t th y i t d th id p i lly t i g g i t th
| g i f thi i g d h l f id b d Th l g i g f h |
| f bl lpt bl t k by L |
h di g h ld ll d pid i f h P h
bl j i f i b t d pl Th
h ld i th B iti h M i l d Elgi i h ly i h y;
f d d th h b ll f th i t t G A g th i g
t d by th B iti h M f k pi g h h b h t d i g b t f th i p ti A j h ll g t hi h h f l ti
f d g d by h l i g th d d by th At diff t p i t i i h h i l d d h f i h i l d id ll
d i l A t i l i g i h 930 id ly d d i l di g
by l t B i i h M di f l i g ig ifi f d il 20 All f hi d k i p t h d t b li
id d t h t i gi d t b th lpt igi l p hi
| S h l h i i gly q ti d th id th t th g bl h q i l f d t th t i it ly pp |
b ti t th
d f th y i B iti h h d S h gg t d th t it i t lly p d d by th bl it lf (th gh thi id i l g d d lik ly) h i i ith i t i l pig t
S Clé i D li Th M t b li M B li 2020
20 S I J ki Cl i g d C t y Th P th S lpt 8 939 L d 200
h f igi l p ti ppli d th i f h i ki g 2 If th
h f th id th th h ld id h g l ff f p i h i h i f h lli g f thi i ll th
f h bl b f d f h i gf l pti i y p i i y i hi h th y h ly ff d f th h
| di d b th id id I t d ith y th f t f h i l di g hi hi |
I ll f th
th y gl d
d t t ti d l d th y p ibiliti f p i di pl y d tit i g h t l d p t ti l i R id l l
gi h d p ifi lly h bj t d i tit i p i
p h p di ly d di p t bly d i th d h h th i ll f th b i gi d d li d i p i l y
C sx s s
Eth g phi h d th p l gi l ibility t th ly t b i g id d th id l k ith d g i t h i t
l gi l t i Th l i i d h i t ll i k th t h f d id p i lly d d i d i g h lik i highligh d
gl d lt i l gi H I d p p id id
y f h k b h l t f h l gi l i ight h t h y b i g 22
F phil ph Mi h l M d h t d t ight f d t
| d hil f g di g th d id l tt ti th t ti t |
d l p g th t h ll D t t i l gi l i k y f t f d t i th t it l g t th f f thi g t th b kg
t i l f hi h t k d 23 Gi th h
ypi lly b i g t b it f ll h t p i ly i p p ibl t /d t [ ] i
| k it lf 24 A ly d hä ) by M l D h p |
i p i g p h p ibility f it b i g p f th t k d g i g q ti b t h i l d t p l bili y f h t
f pl f 920 i C A ch f (ßk f c O
| y titl f th k p l ly th id f d t ti d A M d d ib it |
d M R y Th i d d p lif ti
2 S f pl A i i G l Y D g i Th R t th Epid i f th P th
I St di i C ti l 48 2003 pp 3 6
22 F f th pl M d ( t 4) M ij Ni h i Ag N D t A P f t Ci
l ity I C lt l G g phi l 25 20 8 3 pp 50 7; d M il P l ti B y d I h t D b i D t i C p y C l I E p J l f E gli h S di l 5 20 pp
73 84
23 M d ( t 4) p 96
24 Ibid
R fgs f sg C s @ss c f s sg L sg fg s Q c 8
E x C g o k c k g a j e gh h 1 64 kk j Th B id S ipp d B by h B h l E ’08 3 12( k h kx
h k c Th L g Gl Vg g k x e c gh j fg Q x h h c C g o A c x ch h M W j g g c g oh ok c ax o
h c Sg g og f og c g cx c h g g o
o g “ f h e h x o kk h h c h g g o ee e c g hf e g h khe c j 14
| h i d i h i h i h th t k pl y |
L D h p d f th d t d d p ly i t g i g th d t i th k 26 A
i g d h i i d p d i h gh it d pl y I h f C
A ch f M d p i it l i d t ll b i g i h d di g d i g p f th b id 27 I d d d d th id t yi g t i p i lly t i th t it i ltipl ll b i g f h b tt
f x g d th i b ti ( St d p t it) f th ti d pl 28 A ti t Alli C t f pl tili h h ld d t f
l ; Al d O i h id f b p ll i i t ffi l 29 Th id f f b i g di ; th y i g l t th k d h i
Th h d k h di ly dd th i lf O t bl pl i th ? L C B kk h b g i 996 by ti t d di t
f th J h E i k M f A t S Mill A ti i g k it h i l d t ki g ph t g ph f d t t i pi l f d
| th ld 30 A Mill pl i y t i d di pp i t i hi th p Th l i |
th g d d t
b t fli i th
| d i d p ti t di h ld f th d t hi b p D t t b d p h i t g ity |
f f h i hit b g ll y
d f ll y f th i l bj i hit b 3
25 Ibid p 97
26 S Ibid
27 Ibid p 00
28 S d ( 3) p 6
29 M d ( t 4) pp 0 3
30 S h tp // ill t di t/ d t ( f 5/2022)
3 K lly C bb S Mill A M D t C ll ti W i g A y M G d D t B
i Whi Li d N M I T til Th J l f Cl h d N M l 8 20 5 3 pp 286 302

M J s g c Sg C s s O sg L 1/ 5 s e sg c sx s
I t i gly Ni S l h b d thi id f d hi g h M y D gl ight t t t f pl i l id t i th i t l p f
p t d th i g th y g t 32 Th gh th d itt p l i
f d t p digit l d l phy i l t d l p d ti l Th gh hi ti h Mill k t t f th d i l f d t i th t
A d i hyb id f d yi g h i i ti h
di ti t th l d d i i t D thi y th i i y b th p d b if l p i y 33
I h igh b th f f d t b di g f d p f t i l ity ti t K lly C bb h k d Mill ph t g ph f d t i t f b i hi h th l hibit d i 34 D t d d g d
32 S Ni S l D t l ff th d t p k Th y l Üb g tö t h t d b g C p t bild I R b t S t G ttf i d B h Th t B th ( d ) P kä Bild
L id 20 0 pp 247 75 F M y D gl t M y D gl P ity d D g L d 966
33 C bb Mill ( t 3 ) p 290
34 St d ( t 3) p 6; K lly C bb A t M D t C ll ti http //k lly bb t bl / d ( f 5/2022)
Ni K h d i C F g h f (20 6 7) t h M f M d A i N Y k lik i f h f h d t b h h
l b d i f p i bj t d p
E f A th li d ipti p t it D
| i t f t i l f | b | th i | id | d | t id | ||||
| f E th d th | f | pl | y high | ||||||
| d y l | d t th M it li | lly | |||||||
| i i gli ld 35 Al | g f diff p pl f g id ki g thi d i ibl | h | d th gh | ||||||
| ph t g ph | K t h d i lik th h | g | phi | ||||||
| k b | k b i g h p pl | t d | |||||||
| ith i | g d t d th i k i t | ||||||||
| th | gh | t | ig ifi | tly t | ight th | gh | di | ||
| i t | i | i h th | |||||||
Whil f th k i k th
b i f h ti d pl d f th i
ti f h t h d h f g ll y p h y d t di ly i ig t h

- B V j V j x c s o
c sg f s ü s g U s x @ s x Sg s ’S@ S(
A k bl k h t d i i ll ti d by d ig Cl Wi kl p t f th hibiti R gh f L h kh h p d d ithi h f
k f th Cl t f E ll L e ? h h x 36 E f 1 5 E di g l i fi ti k f ly d ig h Wi kl i t ll ti t il d li t i g th l f th hibiti p f th Ti t i h Th (V t i y A y Th ) ll d pl kly Th pl di pl y d i
b i h g ll y d ly d i pi lly d h p f h d t Thi l d id i f f diff l i l di g i d t d ( h f t d t i th f i d h g phi pl l i d) d
th t i d d t d by th b ildi g (i thi li ) ll th
h p ll b ght i by i it Th b kd f h pl di pl y d th hibi i ll h t d th h gi g p t f d t h y h i g t
35 M MA D t G h i g A A di E p i by Ni K t h d i http // g/ l d / hibiti /36 0 ( f 5/2022)
36 M tt f A i ity E hibiti St t hi g M i liti Hidd A ti iti i Obj t d Sp t th V t i y A t y Th t h tp // t f ti ity d / / i iti /6006/ hibiti t t h i g i liti ( f 4/2022) I d h l Cl Wi kl At ph i th M ki g A Cl d Mi bi p bli h d y
B V jk @ f sg V sg f R o f V


Bk V jk @ f sg V sg f R o f V o
ly h d t i ltipl b t h i
p i i l yi g hif i g b
ti diff t i A i h h t f thi hibi i Wi kl d t i ll i
ght t highlight d i hi h
i lity ld b t h d i thi by tt di g t h i pi i l di t h ti ll d h
d by h i g h I d i g th k l d th lly hidd ti ity
f h hibi i p hi h t h ll h i lf
| B Thi ti l i g t id t id |
h pl d f tt d
i d f i d h t thi ight b i g t ligh
| f h id F h pl f M t ph i h A th |
d di g f
t p i h d h gh li l t i l id
l f y
t d b h l t
i Gl g i t d th i t ith th g i th th y
kli g; h i id th l gi l bj p k l q ly f h p i
| f | l | i l pp p i ti | ; | d h | k | ll | ph | i l | b | ||||||
| i | ft | l ipl By pl | i g | p | i | d | p | l | id | ( d | d |
t p k d t bi h d t) thi ti l h h th b tit i th t di t p ti l hi hi hi i d t l gi
| T tt d t t i l d t ight th d t i t tt d t th t i lity f Oft h h t i li y i i k d thi i i gi d i t f bj t ti f th i hit t R id h di t h g t i l l th d bili h b d d f h bj t i lf p i g ti l t l g I p h i k h i hif f bj t |
i
i
| i l B it i di l i h i t h h kh h hibi i h d ll b y d th |
t
R gh f L
thi f th th
t i l h k
p bj d i th ti d t th id l

Bk V j c Rj c G sg ah Lh ah e @h a O s L a o f sg L j L@R // D @ R o sg g a s o es s f sg

B Vh jk c K jc O k D s ä c RDL og s f ogx e
o c s sg s e S@ S c B c jc
- id l i hi thi ti l h b th i f p i R id pl y i t thi i p t d b t p f l y t iki gly id t i th f th pid i f th P th bl d f h th l gi l bj t h p t ti l tit ti i d d t b h p d by th i id h W igh l k h th
bj t p i id i p d by th A f th g f fig
| p t i l lyti l i ig i f hif i d ll f b i i p |
d g d d h
h h q i
l i th i 37
g f t h
ti thi ki g
Q hc i t y t t g l ly pl y d i l gi l ly i
| y id lity h gi it t ti f t light h th y f |
b i gi g lly k d di i
t th t th y id d th t
| l li g t i p i h th t bj h ld b i h id I hi ti l |
k b tl g i h d h ld b l d h
I h gh b i g j t id b t id l ti ighti g h d t t h f I y thi i p d i l i i g th q i f h h h id l i till id l h it i d g H th d t ill ttl th t q ti
d i d d h h it ill d i h tt th t f t i (i l di g i thi y) l d d id l
37 S M ily St th O Sp d D pth I J h L A i M l ( d ) C pl iti S i l
37 di f K l dg P i D h NC 2002 pp 88 5